"Supertoys Last All Summer Long" by Brian Aldiss in Adaptations: From Short Story to Big Screen.*
ISBN: 97814000053148.
One of the major reasons I've never really wanted a child is that I
can't see myself loving something the way that most people seem to love
their children. It's like they sort of lose all reason when it comes
down to this one (or more) person(s) in their life and nothing you
can say or do will make them behave rationally. I just don't see
myself loving in that way, and I don't know if I'm more afraid of not
being able to or of turning into one of those people.
I'm not at all suggesting that it is a bad thing to love your child so
much. I just don't know that it's for me. I even like children
somewhat, as a concept. I like what they represent and the way they
tend to look at the world with these very plastic and fluid brains that
haven't quite figured out the concept of "wrong" or "inconceivable"
yet. They can and do imagine everything, which is why I think they're
so amazing, but I would never, ever want to have one, because oh god the
terrible things I might do to something so precious.
But what if I could have a make-believe child? A robot child that I
could love and who could love me, and whose brain I could just wipe
clean whenever it got too "old" mentally? Would I actually be able to
feel love for an android child? I don't think I could, and I don't
think that anyone else could either. It has nothing to do with the "not
of my body" issue, although I imagine there are foster and adoptive
parents who struggle to learn to love their adopted children (and
probably love them all the more for those difficulties).
I think it has more to do with the fact that even though we know how
children are made (unless you've undergone abstinence only programs), we
don't really know how they are made. There is a degree of
randomness in it, the thrill of the unknown and the unpredictable, not
only in creating the child, but in raising him or her. I think this
would be nearly impossible to program into an android child, because
even with artificial intelligence, it will still act like a robot and
there are things that a robot simply cannot do.
A robot does not need to be cared for in the middle of the night because of fevers or chicken pox or bad dreams. A robot does not need to have
scraped knees kissed or small cuts bandaged just to make him or her feel
better. Granted I'm sure they would have their own mechanical problems
that equated to illness or bodily damage, and you could probably even
program the android child to have bad dream responses. But why would
anyone in their right minds want their children to have
nightmares? Or diseases? Or broken bones? Or hurt feelings? Yet these are the very things that make them our children, not
necessarily the things themselves, but in how we tend to them, care for
them, and teach our children to endure them and become better people.
With an android it would just feel like I was teaching the program how
to beat me in chess, in the sense that I would be teaching it how to be a
better human than I am, which completely defeats the purpose of being
human.
We are designed to make mistakes. And somehow I don't think that
designing mistakes into an A.I. would solve the problem, the artifice
just produces more artifice. We love our children so insanely because
they are so completely unpredictable. We can "program" them any way we
want to, but they still have their own directives and will follow them
passionately in the face of all obstacles. So while I can love (or
hate) my car in the way that I can love any object, there is something
particularly beautiful and untouchable in the way that people love
children. It is so vastly different from the way that we love other people or our animals.
It's as if that mixture of the bits of yourself and your partner and
your respective relatives and all of the lessons you've taught the child
still cannot account for the unknown element that the child carries
within him- or herself. And I think it's that unknown element that we
really love, because it's the one thing we know we can't grasp or
influence and we revel in that. We live in the joy that is that child's own, unique, and
absolutely amazing ability to completely rip our
hearts to pieces, and somehow make them bigger and better and more full
of love than ever. I would hate to see that kind of love wasted on a 1967 Corvette, no matter how beautiful it is.
*Film adaptation is A.I. Artificial Intelligence
No comments:
Post a Comment